Support Savannah Agenda

Make a one-time contribution or monthly payment for as low as $1
$
Secure payment via Stripe

By Eric Curl

Nov. 15, 2026 – Chatham County is moving forward with plans to construct a new library while failing to address questions surrounding the property purchase for the SPLOST-funded project and ignoring inquiries on the status of an open-records request concerning the matter.

Subscribe to Savannah Agenda’s newsletter

* indicates required

Savannah Agenda submitted the records request on Sept. 10 after learning Chatham County acquired the property at the Eisenhower Square shopping center for $3.5 million in 2022 without a public vote and that the seller had purchased the property less than two months earlier for $1.25 million.

Meanwhile, the county issued an invitation for bids on Nov. 9 for construction of the new library at the acquired site, which will replace the existing Oglethorpe Library near Oglethorpe Mall, following a presentation of conceptual designs for the building in August.

Chatham County is planning to build the new library on a portion of the Eisenhower Square shopping center’s parking lot. Eric Curl/Nov. 11, 2026

The purchase

Property records show JTM Property Holdings LLC purchased the 4.16-acre parcel near Eisenhower Drive and Waters Avenue for $1.25 million on June 15, 2022, before selling it to Chatham County for $3.5 million on Aug. 9, 2022.

The Chatham County Commission never voted in public to approve the property purchase or price, despite state open-meetings law requiring that any real estate acquisition decisions made in executive session be approved in a subsequent public vote.

County Attorney Jon Hart defended the lack of a public vote, claiming no additional approval was necessary because the library project had been included in a sales-tax resolution (SPLOST) approved by voters.

Hart’s explanation came as a response to an August open-records request for any records concerning Chatham’s authorization of the property purchase, including any meeting minutes, agendas or supporting documents. The documents the county provided included a 2019 SPLOST referendum, which did not mention a library, and an agreement with the Live Oak Public Libraries concerning the construction and funding of the library. Funding for the library was actually authorized in the 2013 SPLOST referendum, as indicated in the agreement, although the document did not mention a specific location, simply noting a $5 million allocation for “Libraries (Oglethorpe).”

Georgia open-meeting law pertaining real estate acquisitions

Catherine Glasby, Chatham’s public Information director, echoed Hart’s claim, stating in an Aug. 31 email that the purchase was “approved by the Board of Commissioners as part of the SPLOST resolution.”

“The Board approved the project list in the resolution and then the voters of Chatham County approved the SPLOST via a referendum,” Glasby said. “The acquisition does not need to come back to the Commission for further approval since the voters approved the SPLOST.”

State law allows real estate acquisitions to be discussed behind closed doors during executive session, but also says that any vote taken in executive session to acquire property is not binding until a subsequent vote is taken in an open meeting, with the identity of the property and the terms of the acquisition disclosed before the vote.

The county did not respond to requests for a specific provision of state law, county ordinance or rule establishing that a broadly approved SPLOST capital project authorizes staff to spend $3.5 million on a particular parcel without subsequent commission action. The county also did not respond to an inquiry as to whether any circumstance exists in which a SPLOST-funded real estate acquisition would require a public vote before the board of commissioners.

The property Chatham County purchased for the new library is shown in blue. The building on the parcel, a movie theater, had already been demolished and is now a vacant lot. Source: SAGIS.org

The request

The Sept. 10 request seeks records concerning the county’s purchase from JTM Property Holdings LLC, including appraisals, correspondence and documents indicating whether county officials knew JTM had purchased the property for $1.25 million just 55 days earlier.

The open-records request followed questions Savannah Agenda submitted to the county’s communications office on Sept. 9 about the property purchase. On the same day JTM acquired the future library site, Eisenhower Square LLC, a separate company listing the same Charlotte address, purchased the adjoining shopping center for $11.25 million. County Attorney Jon Hart suggested that the difference in prices reflected how the buyers allocated the properties’ values, assigning more value to the shopping center for tax depreciation and financing purposes.

Hart said the county valued the land and parking lot improvements at approximately $3.75 million to $3.9 million and considered the $3.5 million purchase a good deal. The county assessor’s office appraised the property’s value at about $2.7 million each year since the acquisition, according to property records.

Hart did not answer questions about whether the county was aware that JTM had purchased the property for $1.25 million less than two months earlier or whether the county obtained an independent valuation before agreeing to the $3.5 million price.

After the open-records request was submitted on Sept. 10, the county initially responded that it anticipated providing the documents within 30 days. After that period passed, the county extended its anticipated production date to Nov. 6, following multiple inquiries about the request’s status that initially went unanswered. The notification of the anticipated Nov. 6 date was sent on Oct. 23, a day after Savannah Agenda informed the county of its intention to file a complaint with the Georgia Attorney General’s Open Government Mediation Program.

As of Nov. 15, the county had provided none of the requested documents, offered no explanation for missing its revised Nov. 6 production date and given no indication of when the records would be released, despite follow-up inquiries on Nov. 6, and Nov. 10. On Nov. 10, the county’s communications department was informed of this article’s pending publication and asked for comment. The office did not respond.

Renderings of the new library by GMShay Architects as presented to county commissioners in August 2026. Source: GMShay Architects.

The library

On Nov. 9, the county issued an invitation for bids for the library’s construction. The solicitation comes after Chatham County officials unveiled conceptual plans to the county commission in August for the new library, which they said is expected to open in mid-2028.

The roughly 17,000-square-foot building is to be constructed largely with mass timber, much of it sourced from Georgia, and include a central courtyard, community meeting rooms, children’s and adult reading areas, a makerspace, outdoor gathering spaces and rooftop solar panels, according to Architect Patrick Shay. 

The new library will replace the existing Oglethorpe Library, which library officials say is outdated and too small to meet the needs of the growing population.

Oglethorpe Mall Library – ABOUT THE LIBRARY

In response to a Savannah Agenda inquiry, a library spokesperson said in September that the selection of the site for the replacement library building was made by Chatham County, therefore no vote by any Live Oak Public Library board or committee was required or taken.

“This is a Chatham County project,” Betsy McCullar, director of communications and partnerships, said in a Sept. 11 email. “When the building is complete, it will be turned over to Live Oak Public Library for operations.”

Support Savannah Agenda

Make a onetime contribution or monthly payment as low as $1
  • $
Secure payment via Stripe

If you find value in this website, please consider contributing above or via Paypal to help cover the costs. You can also send contributions via Venmo @Savannah_Agenda. Your support, no matter how much you give, is appreciated and will help ensure the future viability of this community resource. You can also show your support by subscribing below and sharing Savannah Agenda with others via email or social media. Increasing readership is critical to the long-term success of this site.

Subscribe to Savannah Agenda’s newsletter

* indicates required

Check out Savannah Agenda’s latest newsletter>

TOP POSTS

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *